Daf 90 — Chullin 90 Summary

Chullin 90 – Good Morning Raboisai Gid Hanasheh & Kodshim – Two Issurim Gemara: Case: • Eating the gid hanasheh of a korban Question Is one liable for: • Gid hanasheh • And kodshim Answer Yes – two issurim can apply Reason: • Gid hanasheh is a more severe issur Source of Severity Gid hanasheh: • Applies even to Bnei Noach Therefore: • Considered a stronger issur Who Holds This Rabbi Yehuda: • Holds gid hanasheh applies to Bnei Noach Issue But Rabbi Yehuda also says: • Only one thigh is forbidden Yet Mishnah says: • Both thighs Resolution We combine views: • Like Rabbi Yehuda (severity) • Not like him (both thighs) Limit of Issur on Issur Cannot always add an issur Example: • Kodshim (kareis) is already very severe So: • Another issur may not apply Bechor Case Firstborn animal: • Becomes kadosh at birth Timing: • Gid hanasheh may come before or at same time Result Possible to have both issurim Alternative – Regular Kodshim Animal designated as korban Kedusha: • Takes effect at birth Allows: • Issurim to align or combine New Sugya – Edible vs Non - Edible Key distinction: • Edible korban vs non - edible (olah) Rule If edible: • Gid hanasheh applies If not edible: • Different treatment Machlokes – Bringing to Mizbeach Can gid hanasheh go on mizbeach? One view: • Yes if attached Other view: • No כלל If parts are: • Attached → go on mizbeach Detached → do not Source from Pasuk “Bring everything” Includes: • Bones • Sinews • Horns Limitation Only when attached Rebbe’s View Even forbidden parts: • Can go on mizbeach if attached Rabbanan Only items permitted for eating Exclude: • Gid hanasheh Practical Result Gid hanasheh: • Removed Placed on: • Tapuach (pile on mizbeach) Why Not Remove Earlier Better to bring: • Whole, complete korban Then remove Guzma (Exaggeration) Chazal sometimes exaggerate Examples: • 300 kur on mizbeach • 300 kohanim • Golden vessels Principle Torah / Chazal / Neviim: • Use exaggeration in language Paroches Example Thickness: • One tefach 300 kohanim needed Example of guzma New Sugya – Which Thigh Machlokes: • Both thighs or one Rabbi Yehuda: • Only one side Question Which side? Possibilities: • Right side • Or uncertainty Proof from Korban Pesach Sinews burned If only one side forbidden: • Why burn both? Answer They became mixed Cannot identify Final Points • Gid hanasheh can combine with other issurim • Severity allows issur to apply on issur • Timing (birth / development) is critical • Mizbeach rules depend on attachment • Guzma is common in Chazal • Gid hanasheh location debated • Safek leads to burning mixture Catch up, review, download previous Dafim & more: https://www.dafchazarah.co.uk Now available as an app (Apple, Google & Amazon): https://dafchazarah.co.uk/download Sponsor a day: https://dafchazarah.co.uk/sponsor לעילוי נשמת אמי מורתי רות בת הרב מנחם מנדל