Daf 91 — Chullin 91 Summary

Chullin 91 – Good Morning Raboisai Why Mention Gid Separately (Korban Pesach) Gemara: Question: • Why list gid separately from meat? Answer 1 Refers to: • Fat of the gid Even though: • Technically permitted Klal Yisrael: • Did not eat it Therefore: • Considered leftover → must be burned Kedusha – Abstaining Key idea: • Kedusha = abstaining even from permitted things Answer 2 – Two Gidim There are: • Two sinews Inner gid: • Asur mid’Oraisa Outer gid: • Asur mid’Rabbanan Since people avoid both: • Both treated as leftover → burned Rabbi Yehuda – One Side or Safek Question: • Does he know which side is asur? Proof From malkus case If safek: • Cannot give warning Conclusion: • Rabbi Yehuda knows → one specific side Asra Safek Machlokes: • Is warning in doubt valid? Rabbi Yehuda: • Holds it can work Proof from: • Noisar case Case – Two Gidim Eaten If from: • Two animals Chachamim: • Can be liable twice Rabbi Yehuda: • Only one side → limits liability Why Only 40 Malkus Case: • Combined shiur Less than kezayis each Together → one kezayis Therefore: • Only one liability Which Side is Asur Conclusion: • Right thigh Reason Based on: • How the malach struck Yaakov How the Malach Attacked Several explanations: • Wrestled and reached around • Came like a non - Jew • Came like a talmid chacham • Came from behind Result: • Injury to right side Dust Reaching Heaven During struggle: • Dust rose up דרשה “Vaye’avek” = • Dust rising Yosef’s Shechita Yosef showed: • Proper shechita Also: • Removed gid hanasheh Yaakov and Small Items Returned for: • Small vessels Lesson Tzadikim: • Careful with money Not Going Out at Night Source: • Yaakov was alone at night Result: • Danger from mazikin Rule: • Talmid chacham should not go alone at night Torah in All Situations Even: • Wedding day • Busy situations Continue learning Torah Sun for Yaakov Sun set early: • For him Rose early: • For him Idea Hashem changes nature for tzaddikim Stones Became One Stones argued: • Each wanted Yaakov’s head Became: • One stone Ladder & Malachim Angels: • Went up and down Saw: • Yaakov’s image above and below Land Folded Hashem: • Folded Eretz Yisrael under him Result Easier for descendants to inherit Final Points • Gid hanasheh has multiple layers (fat, inner, outer) • Rabbi Yehuda holds one side (right) • Asra safek can still be valid • Liability depends on shiur and cases • Malach striking Yaakov defines halacha • Many aggados teach humility, care, and protection • Tzadikim influence nature and history Catch up, review, download previous Dafim & more: https://www.dafchazarah.co.uk Now available as an app (Apple, Google & Amazon): https://dafchazarah.co.uk/download Sponsor a day: https://dafchazarah.co.uk/sponsor לעילוי נשמת אמי מורתי רות בת הרב מנחם מנדל