בכורות•Bechoros
Daf 58 — Bechoros 58 Summary
Bechoros 58 summary · Daf Yomi chazarah notes
58
Daily chazarah summary for Bechoros Daf 58
Uploaded November 15, 2026
Share:
View PDF
Daf Yomi summary — Bechoros 58
Bechoros 58 – Good Morning Raboisai Three Granos for Ma’aser Behemah The Mishnah teaches that there are: Shalosh Granos – three designated periods during the year for Ma’aser Behemah. The word Goren is borrowed from produce. Just as produce reaches a stage when Ma’aser must be dealt with: Chazal established three times during the year when a person should separate Ma’aser Behemah from the animals born since the previous Goren. These times are connected to: Pesach Shavuos Sukkos Can You Eat an Animal Before Ma’aser? There is a major difference between: Ma’aser of produce and: Ma’aser Behemah. Produce that has reached its obligation but has not been tithed can become: Tevel – prohibited to eat. Ma’aser Behemah is different. Rashi explains: Fundamentally, before the Goren arrives, the owner may shecht and eat an animal even though he has not yet separated Ma’aser Behemah. The obligation is: A Mitzvah to designate every tenth animal. Once the designated Goren arrives, however: Chazal said he should not shecht or sell the animals before taking Ma’aser. When Are the Three Granos? Rebbi Akiva – Fifteen Days Before According to Rebbi Akiva, the three Granos are: Pras HaPesach Pras HaAtzeres Pras HaChag Pras means: Half. The normal period discussed before a Yom Tov is thirty days. Half of thirty is: Fifteen days. Therefore, according to Rebbi Akiva: Ma’aser Behemah is separated fifteen days before each of the three Regalim. Why Doesn't Rebbi Akiva Give a Date Before Pesach? Fifteen days before Pesach can fall on: The 29th or 30th of Adar, depending on the length of the month. Therefore, Rebbi Akiva does not give: One fixed calendar date. He simply says: Fifteen days before Pesach. Ben Azai’s Dates Ben Azai gives specific dates: 29 Adar 1 Sivan 29 Av His dates differ from Rebbi Akiva because: He calculates the Granos differently. In particular, the Shavuos Goren is pushed much closer to Shavuos. Why So Close to Shavuos? There are only: Fifty days between Pesach and Shavuos. If Ma’aser were taken fifteen days before Shavuos: There would be a very short period for additional animals to be born after the Pesach Goren. Therefore: The Shavuos Goren is pushed closer to Shavuos. This allows: More newborn animals to accumulate. Rebbi Elazar and Rebbi Shimon Rebbi Elazar and Rebbi Shimon give another set of dates: 1 Nissan 1 Sivan 29 Elul Why 29 Elul rather than: 1 Tishrei? Because 1 Tishrei is: Rosh Hashanah – Yom Tov. During the Ma’aser process the tenth animal is normally: Marked with red paint. Painting cannot be done on Yom Tov. Therefore: The Goren is moved to 29 Elul. Why Before the Regalim? Animals for the Olei Regalim Why did Chazal establish these periods around: Pesach, Shavuos and Sukkos? Because large numbers of people would come to Yerushalayim: For Aliyah LaRegel. They needed animals: For Korbanos and for food. Chazal therefore wanted animals to become available: Before the crowds arrived. The Owner Wants to Perform the Mitzvah First Before the Goren: An owner could technically sell or shecht his animals. But a Yid would prefer: To first perform the Mitzvah of Ma’aser Behemah. Once the tenth animal becomes Ma’aser: He brings it to Yerushalayim and eats it there. The Daf notes an additional benefit: The owner can eat the animal without the ordinary Matnos Kehunah obligation applying in the usual way. So he gains: A Mitzvah without losing the animal. Rosh Hashanah for Ma’aser Behemah Rebbi Meir – 1 Elul We now come to a different issue: When does the Ma’aser Behemah year begin? According to Rebbi Meir: 1 Elul is Rosh Hashanah for Ma’aser Behemah. Therefore: Animals born before 1 Elul belong to one Ma’aser year. Animals born from 1 Elul onward belong to the next. Animals from the two years: Cannot combine. Rebbi Elazar and Rebbi Shimon – 1 Tishrei According to Rebbi Elazar and Rebbi Shimon: 1 Tishrei is Rosh Hashanah for Ma’aser Behemah. Therefore: Elul still belongs to the previous year. The new Ma’aser year begins: On Rosh Hashanah. Ben Azai – Elul Stands Alone Elulim Mis’asrin Bifnei Atzman Ben Azai is unsure which tradition is correct: Is Rosh Hashanah for Ma’aser Behemah 1 Elul? or: 1 Tishrei? Therefore, he rules: Animals born during Elul are tithed separately. They do not combine with: Animals born in Av. And they do not combine with: Animals born in Tishrei. Elul becomes: Its own separate category. Why Couldn't Ben Azai Decide? The Gemara asks: Ben Azai was an extraordinary Talmid Chacham. Why couldn't he simply analyze the opinions and decide: Which one made more sense? Rebbi Yochanan answers: Mipi HaShemuah Amruha. The dates were based on: A received tradition. They were not based simply on: A logical argument that Ben Azai could weigh and decide. Therefore: He treated Elul separately to satisfy both possibilities. Crossing a Goren Is Not a New Year Five Before and Five After a Goren Suppose: Five animals are born before one of the three Granos. Five are born afterwards. Can they combine? Yes. The Goren does not create: A new Ma’aser year. It merely establishes: The time when Ma’aser should be taken. Therefore, animals on opposite sides of a Goren: Can still combine if they belong to the same Ma’aser year. Crossing Rosh Hashanah Is Different But suppose: Five animals are born before Rosh Hashanah for Ma’aser Behemah. Five are born afterwards. They cannot combine. Why? Because: Chodosh and Yashan – animals from different Ma’aser years – cannot be joined together. So we have an important distinction: Goren = timing for separating Ma’aser. Rosh Hashanah = division between two Ma’aser years. Rava’s Solution for Elul Five – Five – Five Ben Azai creates a practical problem. Suppose someone has: Five animals from Av. Five animals from Elul. Five animals from Tishrei. The Elul animals: Cannot simply combine with either side because we do not know whether the year changed at the beginning or end of Elul. Rava gives a clever solution. Whichever Way You Look at It The five Av animals and five Tishrei animals: Definitely cannot combine with each other. But the five Elul animals must belong: Either with Av or: With Tishrei. Therefore: They can be counted in a carefully arranged way so that the tenth animal comes from the Elul group. Whichever Rosh Hashanah is correct: The Elul animal can become the valid Ma’aser. Counting While the Animals Are Stationary Normally we picture Ma’aser Behemah as: Animals leaving a pen one by one. But Rava's solution relies on another Halachah: Counting can work even when the animals are stationary. If the animals are: Revutzim – lying or standing in place, the owner can still count them and designate the tenth. This is not the ideal procedure: But the Ma’aser is valid. This allows him to make sure: The tenth comes from the Elul group. How Ma’aser Behemah Is Normally Performed The Pen The Mishnah describes the normal procedure. The owner gathers the animals: Into a pen. He creates: A small opening through which they can leave one at a time. He counts: One, two, three... until: The tenth emerges. Marking the Tenth Animal When the tenth animal emerges: The owner marks it with red paint. He declares: This is Ma’aser. The marking makes the Ma’aser animal: Easily identifiable. But the Daf teaches: The paint itself is not Me’akev. What if He Didn't Use a Staff or Paint? Suppose the owner: Did not mark the animal. Or: Did not count them in the ideal manner. Or even: Counted them while they were sitting or standing rather than passing through the opening. The Ma’aser can nevertheless: Take effect. The normal procedure is the proper way to perform the Mitzvah: But these details do not necessarily invalidate it. When an Animal Jumps Back Into the Pen A Counted Animal Jumps Back Suppose animals are leaving the pen and being counted. Then: One animal that was already counted jumps back inside. Now there is a serious problem: The owner no longer knows which animals have already been counted. He might count: The same animal twice. The remaining animals therefore: Cannot simply continue through the normal count. What if the Ma’aser Animal Jumps Back? An even greater problem occurs if: An animal already designated as Ma’aser jumps back into the flock. Now a Kadosh animal: Is mixed with ordinary animals. The owner cannot simply eat the flock because: One of them is Ma’aser Behemah. The Daf indicates that the animals must be handled appropriately: Until the Ma’aser animal can be dealt with through a Mum. Key Chazarah • There are three Granos during the year for separating Ma’aser Behemah. • Fundamentally, Ma’aser Behemah is not like Tevel; before the Goren the owner can shecht an animal without first taking Ma’aser. • Once the Goren arrives, Chazal said not to shecht or sell before separating Ma’aser. • Rebbi Akiva sets the Granos fifteen days before Pesach, Shavuos and Sukkos. • Ben Azai gives the dates 29 Adar, 1 Sivan and 29 Av. • Rebbi Elazar and Rebbi Shimon give 1 Nissan, 1 Sivan and 29 Elul. • The Shavuos date is close to Shavuos because there is little time for animals to be born between Pesach and Shavuos. • 29 Elul is used rather than Rosh Hashanah because the tenth animal is normally painted and this cannot be done on Yom Tov. • Rebbi Meir holds 1 Elul is Rosh Hashanah for Ma’aser Behemah. • Rebbi Elazar and Rebbi Shimon hold 1 Tishrei is Rosh Hashanah. • Ben Azai therefore treats all animals born during Elul as a separate group. • His uncertainty comes from conflicting received traditions, not an inability to decide a logical argument. • Animals born on opposite sides of a Goren can combine because a Goren does not create a new Ma’aser year. • Animals born on opposite sides of Rosh Hashanah cannot combine. • Rava gives a method using five Av animals, five Elul animals and five Tishrei animals, ensuring that the tenth comes from Elul. • Ma’aser Behemah is normally performed by passing animals one by one through a narrow opening. • The tenth animal is marked with red paint and declared Ma’aser. • The paint and ideal counting procedure are not Me’akev. • If an already - counted animal jumps back into the flock, the count becomes problematic. • If the actual Ma’aser animal becomes mixed back into the flock, the Kadosh animal must be dealt with appropriately. Catch up, review, download previous Dafim & more: https://www.dafchazarah.co.uk Now available as an app (Apple, Google & Amazon): https://dafchazarah.co.uk/download Sponsor a day: https://dafchazarah.co.uk/sponsor לעילוי נשמת אמי מורתי רות בת הרב מנחם מנדל
Translations
Click a language below to generate a free translation: