בכורות•Bechoros

    Daf 57 — Bechoros 57 Summary

    Bechoros 57 summary · Daf Yomi chazarah notes

    57

    Daily chazarah summary for Bechoros Daf 57

    Uploaded November 15, 2026
    Share:

    View PDF

    Open in New Tab

    Daf Yomi summary — Bechoros 57

    Bechoros 57 – Good Morning Raboisai Brothers, Yerushah and Ma’aser Behemah The Daf begins with an important connection between two Halachos: Ma’aser Behemah The Kalbon added when giving the Machatzis HaShekel. When brothers inherit their father's estate, their status depends on whether: The Yerushah remained undivided, or: They divided it and later became partners again. This distinction affects both Halachos. Partners Are Exempt From Ma’aser Behemah A fundamental rule: Animals jointly owned by ordinary partners are exempt from Ma’aser Behemah. Normally, ten eligible animals belonging to one owner are placed in the pen and passed through one at a time: The tenth becomes Ma’aser. But if the animals belong to: Two partners, they are exempt. Where Do We Learn This? The Torah uses plural terminology regarding Bechor: “Bekarchem V’Tzonchem.” A Bechor belonging to partners: Does become Kadosh. Therefore, the exclusion of partnership cannot be referring to Bechor. The Torah's teaching is instead applied to the closely related Mitzvah of: Ma’aser Behemah. The result: Partners are exempt from Ma’aser Behemah. The Kalbon One Shekel for Two Sons When giving the Machatzis HaShekel, there could be an additional small amount called: Kalbon. If a father gives: One full Shekel on behalf of two sons, according to the explanation used in the Daf: Only one Kalbon is required. If the father's estate remains intact and the sons pay from it: It retains the character of the father's property. But once they divide the estate and later create a new partnership: They are now ordinary partners, affecting the Kalbon requirement. Four Possible Cases Rebbi Yirmiyah – Four Combinations Rebbi Yirmiyah points out that these two Halachos can create four possibilities: Chayav in Kalbon and Chayav in Ma’aser Behemah. Patur from Kalbon and Patur from Ma’aser Behemah. Chayav in Kalbon but Patur from Ma’aser Behemah. Chayav in Ma’aser Behemah but Patur from Kalbon. How? Because the brothers' money and animals: Do not necessarily have the same partnership status. Dividing One Part but Not the Other For example, the brothers may: Divide the money but: Leave the animals jointly owned. Or: Divide the animals while: Leaving the money in the original estate. Therefore: The Kalbon status can be different from the Ma’aser Behemah status. Why Is This a Chiddush? The Gemara asks: Peshita! Once we know the two rules, aren't the four combinations obvious? The Chiddush is a case where: The brothers have already divided the animals but have not yet divided the money. We might think: Since they have clearly begun dividing the estate, the money should already be treated as though divided. The Gemara teaches: No. Until the money is actually divided: It retains its original status. Yesh Bereirah What Happens When Brothers Divide? The Daf now enters the major concept of: Yesh Bereirah. Suppose brothers inherit twenty sheep and divide them: Ten to one brother. Ten to the other. How do we view this division? One possibility: The division reveals retroactively that these were the ten animals intended for this brother from the beginning. That is: Yesh Bereirah – retroactive clarification. When They Take Equivalent Property Rav Huna explains that this idea works particularly where each brother receives: The same type of property corresponding to the other. For example: Sheep against sheep. Goats against goats. Equivalent property against equivalent property. We can potentially say: Each brother is merely identifying the portion that was his through Yerushah. Different Property Is Different But suppose: One brother takes sheep. The other takes goats. Or: One takes cash. The other takes real estate. This looks much more like: A transaction between the brothers. They are effectively exchanging their rights in the different assets. In such a case: We cannot simply say the division retroactively clarified what each one originally inherited. Brothers as Purchasers Ein Bereirah The Daf brings the opposing concept: Brothers who divide an inheritance can be treated like purchasers from one another. Each brother originally had: A share throughout the entire estate. When they divide: Each gives up his rights in one asset in exchange for full rights in another. According to this approach: Ein Bereirah. The division is a new transaction rather than a clarification of the original inheritance. Returning at Yovel This has a major consequence regarding: Yovel. If the brothers are treated as purchasers: Their division resembles a sale. Therefore, when Yovel arrives: The properties return and must be divided again. This is because: A purchased Sedeh Achuzah returns at Yovel. Why Discuss Bereirah Twice? Ma’aser Behemah and Yovel The Gemara asks why the issue of Bereirah needs to be taught regarding both: Ma’aser Behemah and: Yovel. Each case contains a possible Chiddush. By Ma’aser Behemah: There is a connection to Bechor, where ownership is naturally clear. By Yovel: The Torah has a special requirement for property to return to its original status. Therefore: We cannot necessarily derive one case from the other. Both are needed. Nine Sheep and a Dog A Fascinating Partnership Case The Daf introduces an unusual case. Two partners divide property. One receives: Ten sheep. The other receives: Nine sheep and a dog. This creates a problem because of: Mechir Kelev. The Torah prohibits bringing as a Korban an animal received in exchange for: A dog. Which Sheep Is the Mechir Kelev? The ten sheep on one side were received in exchange for: Nine sheep plus a dog. Therefore: Some of the value of the dog is represented in the sheep received by the other partner. This potentially gives those sheep the status of: Mechir Kelev, making them unfit for the Mizbe’ach. Could Bereirah Solve the Problem? The Gemara asks: If we say Yesh Bereirah, why not designate: One particular sheep as the one corresponding to the dog? Then: That sheep would be the Mechir Kelev. The remaining nine: Should be permitted. This would seem to support the use of Bereirah. When the Dog Is Worth More The Gemara answers that the case can be where: The dog is worth more than one sheep. Its value therefore corresponds to: One complete sheep plus part of the value of the others. The prohibited value becomes: Spread throughout the group. Therefore: We cannot isolate the entire Mechir Kelev problem in just one sheep. If Their Values Were Equal If the dog were worth exactly: One sheep, then one sheep could potentially correspond to the dog: Leaving the others unaffected. New Mishnah – Which Animals Enter the Pen? Eligible for Ma’aser, Even if Not for a Korban The Mishnah now discusses animals that: Cannot necessarily be brought as ordinary Korbanos, but can nevertheless: Enter the pen for Ma’aser Behemah. This distinction is important. An animal may be disqualified from the Mizbe’ach: Yet still be eligible to become Ma’aser Behemah. Animals That Are Excluded The Mishnah excludes several categories: Kilayim – an animal produced from two different species. Treifah – an animal with a fatal physical defect. Yotzei Dofen – born by Caesarean section. Mechusar Zman – less than eight days old. Yasom – orphaned at birth. These animals are excluded according to the Mishnah's ruling. The Pesukim Behind the Exclusions Shor O Kesev The Torah says: “Shor O Kesev.” This excludes: Kilayim. The animal must belong properly to its stated species. Ki Yivaled The Torah says: “Ki Yivaled” – when it is born. This excludes: Yotzei Dofen. The normal Torah description of birth does not include: An animal removed through the side of its mother. V’Hayah Shivas Yamim The Torah requires the animal to remain: Seven days under its mother. This excludes: Mechusar Zman. The animal does not reach the required stage until: Its eighth day. Tachas Imo The Pasuk says: “Tachas Imo” – under its mother. This excludes: A Yasom. If its mother died at the time of birth: It lacks the required relationship of being under its mother. Tachas - Tachas Ma’aser Behemah and Korbanos The Gemara learns a Gezeirah Shavah: “Tachas” by Ma’aser Behemah from: “Tachas” by Korbanos. This links the eligibility requirements of: Ma’aser Behemah and Korbanos. Certain defects that invalidate an animal for Korbanos: Also exclude it from Ma’aser Behemah. The comparison also teaches: Treifah is excluded. Animals That Still Can Become Ma’aser A Surprising List The Daf then gives a list of animals which, despite serious problems, can still be eligible for Ma’aser Behemah. These include: Rove’a and Nirva – animals involved in certain forbidden relations. Muktzah – designated for Avodah Zarah. Ne’evad – actually worshipped as Avodah Zarah. Esnan – given as payment to a Zonah. Mechir Kelev – received in exchange for a dog. The Chiddush is: Although these animals cannot be offered normally on the Mizbe’ach, they can still enter the Ma’aser Behemah process. Why Are These Different? The Gemara distinguishes between: A physical Pesul and: A disqualification resulting from the animal's history or use. Ma’aser Behemah has a special rule: Even a Ba’al Mum can become Ma’aser. The Torah says not to distinguish: Between “good” and “bad.” Therefore: Certain disqualifications that would prevent ordinary Hakravah do not prevent the animal from becoming Ma’aser Behemah. Tumtum and Androgynous Does Uncertain Gender Matter? The Daf discusses: Tumtum and: Androgynous. Normally, Ma’aser Behemah can apply to: Male or female animals. Therefore, if the only uncertainty is whether an animal is male or female: That need not automatically disqualify it. But there is a Machlokes depending on how the animal's status is understood. Rebbi Shimon Ben Yehudah According to Rebbi Shimon Ben Yehudah: Tumtum and Androgynous do not enter the Ma’aser pen. This depends on whether their status is treated as: Merely an uncertainty between male and female, or: A distinct Halachic category. That distinction determines: Whether they are eligible for Ma’aser Behemah. Rebbi Elazar Ben Yehudah Only Kilayim and Treifah? Another opinion limits the exclusions much more sharply. According to Rebbi Elazar Ben Yehudah: The main exclusions are Kilayim and Treifah. He does not exclude all the other cases listed by the first Tanna. The Gemara explains the different Pesukim and Derashos underlying: Their Machlokes. Can an Orphan Still Have a “Mother”? The Mother’s Hide The Daf concludes the Halachic discussion with a fascinating case. Suppose the mother dies during childbirth. Normally: The newborn is a Yasom. But what if: The mother's hide remains? The hide can be placed around the newborn: To warm and comfort it. The young animal may become attached to it: Almost as though its mother were still present. According to the opinion discussed: Such an animal may no longer be treated as a Yasom for this Halachah. Extraordinary Natural Phenomena The Enormous Cabbage The Daf concludes with remarkable Aggadic descriptions. Rebbi Yehoshua ben Chananya describes: An enormous cabbage in his area. The Gemara uses extraordinarily large measurements to describe: Its leaves and size. These descriptions emphasize: The extraordinary natural phenomena witnessed by the Chachamim. The Giant Cedar Another account describes: An enormous cedar tree that fell. Its size was so extraordinary that: Multiple wagons could pass across its enormous dimensions. Again, the Gemara describes: An astonishing scale far beyond an ordinary tree. The Egg of the Bar Yochni Finally, the Daf describes the enormous bird: Bar Yochni. An egg fell from it and: Flooded sixty cities. It also destroyed: Hundreds of cedar trees. The Gemara asks: Why would the bird throw away its egg? After all: Birds naturally care for their offspring. Rav Ashi answers: The egg was Muzarta – spoiled and incapable of producing a chick. Therefore: The bird discarded it. Key Chazarah • Partners are exempt from Ma’aser Behemah. • The status of brothers depends on whether their father's Yerushah remains intact or was divided and later re - formed as a partnership. • This also affects the Kalbon accompanying Machatzis HaShekel. • Rebbi Yirmiyah describes four possible combinations of liability for Kalbon and Ma’aser Behemah. • Dividing one category of inherited property does not automatically mean the rest is already considered divided. • Yesh Bereirah means a later division can clarify retroactively which property belonged to each brother. • Where brothers take very different assets, the division looks more like a transaction. • If brothers are treated as purchasers, their inherited land can return and be redivided at Yovel. • If ten sheep are exchanged for nine sheep and a dog, Mechir Kelev can affect the sheep received in exchange. • If the dog is worth more than one sheep, its prohibited value can be spread through several animals. • Kilayim, Treifah, Yotzei Dofen, Mechusar Zman and Yasom are discussed as exclusions from Ma’aser Behemah. • The Pesukim “Shor O Kesev,” “Ki Yivaled,” “Shivas Yamim” and “Tachas Imo” provide the sources. • A Tachas - Tachas comparison links Ma’aser Behemah with the laws of Korbanos. • Rove’a, Nirva, Muktzah, Ne’evad, Esnan and Mechir Kelev can nevertheless be eligible for Ma’aser Behemah. • A Ba’al Mum can become Ma’aser Behemah – the Torah says not to distinguish between “good” and “bad.” • Tumtum and Androgynous are subject to a Machlokes regarding eligibility. • The Daf discusses whether a newborn whose mother died can avoid the status of Yasom when the mother's hide remains and is used to nurture it. • The Daf concludes with extraordinary descriptions of a huge cabbage, an enormous cedar and the egg of the Bar Yochni. Catch up, review, download previous Dafim & more: https://www.dafchazarah.co.uk Now available as an app (Apple, Google & Amazon): https://dafchazarah.co.uk/download Sponsor a day: https://dafchazarah.co.uk/sponsor לעילוי נשמת אמי מורתי רות בת הרב מנחם מנדל

    Translations

    Click a language below to generate a free translation: