Daf 118 — Chullin 118 Summary

Chullin 118 – Good Morning Raboisai Perek HaOr VeHaRotev – Tumah of Food Levels of Tumah The Gemara continues the new Perek dealing with Tumah. Tumah works through different levels: • A dead person is Avi Avos HaTumah • One who touches him becomes an Av HaTumah • An Av can make something a Rishon • A Rishon can make food a Sheni For food to convey Tumah of food: • It requires the appropriate shiur, generally a kabeitzah – the volume of an egg. Shomer & Yad What Is a Shomer? A shomer is: • Something that protects food Examples include: • An eggshell • A walnut shell • Fruit peel • Skin protecting meat • A bone protecting marrow Although the shomer itself: • May not be edible It has a halachic connection to: • The food it protects. What Is a Yad? A yad is: • A handle used to hold food For example: • A stem attached to fruit • A bone used to hold a piece of meat Unlike a shomer: • It does not protect the food Its purpose is: • To serve as a handle. A Yad Can Transfer Tumah A yad acts as a connection to the food. Therefore, if: • Tumah touches the handle The Tumah can pass through it: • Into the food. Similarly, if the food is already tamei and its handle touches other food: • Tumah can pass outward through the handle. Two Functions A yad can therefore: • Bring Tumah into the food • Carry Tumah out from the food However: • The yad itself does not combine with the food to complete the required shiur. A Shomer Is Stronger A shomer has an even stronger connection to the food. It can: • Bring Tumah into the food • Carry Tumah out from the food • Combine with the food to complete its required shiur Example If the edible part is slightly less than: • A kabeitzah But together with its protective shell it reaches: • A kabeitzah The shomer can: • Complete the shiur. This is different from: • A yad Which transfers Tumah but: • Does not complete the shiur. Neither Yad Nor Shomer Something that serves as neither: • A handle • Nor protection Has no special connection to the food. For example: • Hair attached to meat that is not used to hold it Therefore: • It does not bring Tumah in • It does not carry Tumah out • It does not combine to complete the shiur. Source for Shomer “Seeds Which Are Planted” The Torah discusses food becoming tamei and refers to: • Seeds which are planted Rebbe Yishmael explains: The Torah compares food regarding Tumah to: • The way seeds are normally planted. When wheat or similar seeds are planted: • They are planted together with their outer covering Therefore: • The protective covering is considered connected to the food. This Teaches A shomer: • Can combine with food • To complete the shiur for Tumah of food. Shomer Does Not Combine with Neveilah Tumah of Neveilah Is Different Although a shomer combines for: • Tumah of food It does not combine to complete the shiur of: • Tumah of neveilah. Tumah of neveilah requires: • A kezayis of actual neveilah. Therefore, if there is: • Less than a kezayis of meat • Plus enough hide to reach a kezayis The hide: • Does not complete the shiur. Touching the Hide However, suppose there is: • A full kezayis of neveilah meat • Covered by its hide And someone touches: • The hide The Gemara teaches that he can become tamei. Why? Although the hide does not: • Combine to create the kezayis It is still connected to: • The actual neveilah And can therefore: • Transfer its Tumah. This highlights the distinction between: • Completing the shiur • Transmitting Tumah. The Rules of Yad and Shomer The Beraisa Summarises A yad without a shomer: • Can receive Tumah • Can transmit Tumah • Does not combine to complete the shiur A shomer: • Can receive Tumah • Can transmit Tumah • Can also combine to complete the shiur Something that is neither: • Does none of these. Where Does the Torah Teach Yad? “Lachem” – For All Your Needs The Gemara searches for the Torah source that: • A handle is considered connected to food. The word: • “Lachem” – for you Is understood to include: • Everything needed for normal use of the food Including: • Its handle. Bringing Tumah In & Taking Tumah Out The Gemara finds multiple pesukim using: • “Lachem” And investigates why: • More than one source is necessary. The two functions that must be established are: • Lahachnis – Tumah entering the food through its handle • Lehotzi – Tumah leaving the food through its handle Meaning: • If Tumah touches the yad, the food becomes tamei • If tamei food’s yad touches another item, Tumah can pass through it. Why Can't We Learn One from the Other? The Gemara repeatedly attempts: • Kal vachomers If a simple handle can transmit Tumah: • Certainly a protector should be able to. And if Tumah can travel: • Into food through the handle Perhaps it should certainly be able to travel: • Out through the handle. The Gemara analyzes which laws: • Require explicit pesukim • And which can be derived logically. Three Torah Sources Seeds, Neveilah & Earthenware Oven The Gemara discusses three separate Torah sections involving Tumah: • Seeds and food • Neveilah • A clay oven Each contains wording from which: • Yad or related Tumah laws Can potentially be derived. The Gemara asks: • Why can't one case teach the others? Why Seeds Cannot Teach Everything Food has a special stringency: • It can receive Tumah through lower levels of Tumah Therefore: • We cannot automatically derive the laws of other Tumah from food. Why an Earthenware Oven Cannot Teach Everything An earthenware oven has a unique Tumah: • A sheretz does not need to touch the oven itself If the sheretz enters: • Its airspace The oven becomes tamei. Because this is unusually stringent: • It cannot automatically serve as the source for other cases. Why Neveilah Cannot Teach Everything Neveilah is also unusually stringent. Its Tumah: • Comes from itself when the animal dies It can also: • Make a person tamei And Tumah can be conveyed through: • Carrying the neveilah. Therefore: • Neveilah cannot simply serve as the source for every other case. Learning from Two Cases Together The Gemara Builds Common - Denominator Derivations The Gemara therefore tries combining: • Two of the three sources To teach: • The third. Each attempt is tested by asking whether the two source cases share: • A special stringency That the third case lacks. This determines which pesukim are: • Truly necessary • And which words may be available for additional derivations. Food Requires Hachshar Food ordinarily cannot receive Tumah until: • It has first come into contact with one of the qualifying liquids. This is: • Hachshar l’kabel Tumah The Gemara considers whether this makes food: • Fundamentally different from the other cases. The discussion ultimately looks for: • A more precise distinction between the various forms of Tumah. Contact vs Airspace One important difference is: Food becomes tamei through: • Contact with Tumah. An earthenware oven can become tamei even without direct contact: • A sheretz entering its airspace is sufficient. This special feature means: • The oven cannot simply be treated like ordinary food. Establishing the Final Sources Yad – Bringing Tumah In The Torah’s discussion of a sheretz falling onto food establishes: • Yad lahachnis Meaning: • Tumah can enter food through its handle. Yad – Taking Tumah Out A separate Torah source establishes: • Yad lehotzi Meaning: • Tumah can travel outward from tamei food through its handle. Once both directions are established for: • A yad The Gemara can use a kal vachomer for: • A shomer. Shomer Can Also Transfer Tumah A shomer is more closely connected to food than: • A mere handle Therefore: If a yad can: • Bring Tumah in • And carry Tumah out Certainly a shomer can: • Bring Tumah in • And carry Tumah out. Why Do We Still Need a Pasuk for Shomer? We still need the Torah's special teaching regarding: • Shomer To establish its additional law: • It combines with the food to complete the required shiur. Final Structure Yad: • Brings Tumah in • Carries Tumah out • Does not combine for the shiur Shomer: • Brings Tumah in • Carries Tumah out • Does combine for the shiur. Shomer of Neveilah Rav Chaviva – It Functions Like a Yad Rav Chaviva explains an important point: When dealing with: • Neveilah The so - called shomer is not functioning in the normal sense of: • Protecting food. The animal is: • Already dead Instead, its connection functions more like: • A yad – a means of transmitting Tumah. This helps explain why: • It can transmit Tumah • But cannot combine to complete the kezayis of neveilah. Pomegranate – Shomer upon a Shomer The Pitom of a Pomegranate The Gemara discusses: • The pitom attached to a pomegranate The pitom can: • Combine with the pomegranate To complete the required shiur for Tumah. Why? It is considered: • A protective part of the fruit. The Nitz – Protection upon Protection Other small parts above the pomegranate: • Do not combine. Why? They are: • A shomer on top of another shomer Meaning: • They protect the peel • Which itself protects the fruit. The Torah includes: • The direct protector of the food But not: • A second layer protecting the protector. Which Foods Have a Shomer? Three Uses of “Zera” The Gemara notes repeated Torah wording concerning: • Seeds From these repetitions, the Gemara includes protective coverings associated with different types of food. These include: • Seeds • Fruit from trees • Meat, eggs and fish Conclusion A shomer is not limited to: • Grain or seeds Rather, the concept applies broadly wherever something serves as: • The direct protection of food. Key Chazarah • A shomer protects food; a yad is a handle used to hold it. • A yad can bring Tumah into food and transmit Tumah outward, but it does not combine to complete the required shiur. • A shomer can bring Tumah in, transmit it outward and also combine with the food to complete its shiur. • Something that is neither a yad nor a shomer has none of these special laws. • The source for shomer comes from the Torah’s description of seeds as they are planted together with their protective coverings. • A shomer combines for Tumah of food, but not to complete the kezayis required for Tumah of neveilah. • If there is already a full kezayis of neveilah, touching its connected hide can transmit Tumah even though the hide itself does not complete the shiur. • The Gemara analyzes separate sources for Yad lahachnis – bringing Tumah in – and Yad lehotzi – carrying Tumah out. • Seeds, neveilah and an earthenware oven each have unique Tumah stringencies, preventing a simple derivation from one to the others. • Once the Torah establishes both functions of a yad, a shomer can be learned by kal vachomer because it is more closely connected to the food. • The additional teaching for shomer establishes that it can actually combine with food to complete the required shiur. • Rav Chaviva explains that the shomer of neveilah effectively functions as a yad for transmitting Tumah rather than as food protection. • The pitom of a pomegranate can combine with the fruit, but a second protective layer does not – it is a shomer on top of a shomer. • The Torah’s repeated wording extends the law of shomer to protective parts of seeds, tree fruits, meat, eggs and fish. Catch up, review, download previous Dafim & more: Daf Chazarah Now available as an app (Apple, Google & Amazon): Download the Daf Chazarah app Sponsor a day לעילוי נשמת אמי מורתי רות בת הרב מנחם מנדל