Daf 106 — Menachos 106 Summary

Menachos 106 – Good Morning Raboisai Safek in Mincha Type • If a person says he will bring a Mincha but is unsure which one Must bring all possible types • Could even be a mixture (Chalos + Rekikin – like Rebbi Shimon) Using a Tenai (Condition) • He says: “Whatever I am chayav is fulfilled” “The rest is Nedavah” • Allows covering all possibilities Problem of Oil (Shemen) • Each Mincha requires oil Question: • What to do with leftover oil ? Cases: • If Chalos → leftover goes into dough • If Rekikin → oil applied differently Problem: • If unsure type → don’t know where oil belongs Solution – Following Rebbi Shimon • All leftover oil goes to Kohanim Removes the safek Question – Why Not Minchas Nesachim? • Maybe when he said “Mincha” he meant: Minchas Nesachim • Can be brought independently Answer – Clear Differences There are clear distinctions between: Regular Mincha vs Nesachim Difference #1 – Individual vs Public • Regular Mincha → individual only • Nesachim → can be communal Difference #2 – Independent vs With Korban • Regular Mincha → stands alone • Nesachim → usually comes with animal Difference #3 – Levonah • Regular Mincha → requires Levonah • Nesachim → no Levonah Difference #4 – Oil Quantity • Regular Mincha → 1 log oil • Nesachim → 3 log oil (or more) Difference #5 – Kmitzah • Regular Mincha → requires Kmitzah • Nesachim → no Kmitzah (all goes on Mizbeach) Conclusion A person will not confuse these types • Differences are too obvious Extreme Case – Forgetting Amount • If person forgot how many Isaron Must bring up to 60 Isaron Case of Single Kli • If he specified: “In one kli” Creates major complications Shitas Chachamim • Bring 60 Isaron in one kli • Use Tenai: o Part = obligation o Part = Nedavah Shitas Rebbi • Cannot mix Chovah and Nedavah Must bring: • 1, 2, 3… up to 60 Isaron Total: • 1830 Isaron Why Not Just Mix? Problems include: • Mixing Chovah + Nedavah • Kmitzah becomes invalid • Cannot bring Chullin into Azarah • Cannot do multiple Hakravos Additional Solutions Discussed • Using multiple Keilim • Connecting Minachos • Turning extra into “wood” Each has limitations Core Machlokes • Can you: Mix different Minachos? Use Tenai effectively? Add beyond original Neder? Key Takeaways • Safek Mincha requires covering all possibilities • Oil handling creates practical halachic challenges • Minchas Nesachim is clearly distinct from regular Mincha • Tenai is powerful but has limitations • Major machlokes between Chachamim and Rebbi on handling uncertainty • Precision in Neder avoids massive complications • Halacha balances practicality with strict structure Catch up, review, download previous Dafim & more: https:// www.dafchazarah.co.uk Now available as an app (Apple, Google & Amazon): https://dafchazarah.co.uk/download Sponsor a day: https://dafchazarah.co.uk/sponsor לעילוי נשמת אמי מורתי רות בת הרב מנחם מנדל