Daf 85 — Chullin 85 Summary

Chullin 85 – Good Morning Raboisai Koi on Shabbos / Yom Tov Gemara: Case: • A “koi” (uncertain animal – part wild, part domesticated) דין If slaughtered: • Do NOT cover the blood on Yom Tov Reason: • Doubt if obligation applies Rabbi Yosi – Opinion Rabbi Yosi says: • Even in a definite case on Shabbos → no covering Therefore: • In a doubtful case on Yom Tov → certainly no covering Proof From bris milah: • Certain case → overrides Shabbos • Doubtful case → does NOT override Yom Tov Challenge from Shofar The Gemara challenges: • In some doubtful cases (shofar) → we still act יסוד Not all doubts are treated the same Smicha (Leaning on Korban) Applies only to: • Men Women: • Not required Mila vs Kisuy HaDam Mila: • Only done during the day Kisuy HaDam: • Can be done at night Insight Cannot always compare between mitzvos Invalid Shechita If shechita is not valid: • No obligation to cover blood Depends on: • Whether it allows eating Machlokes – Validity of Shechita Rav Meir: • Even invalid (not edible) shechita counts Rav Shimon: • Only shechita that allows eating counts Practical Cases Examples: • Treifa • Idol - related slaughter • Incorrect method Result: • May not require covering blood Key Principle Shechita does two things: • Permits eating • Removes impurity Important חילוק Rav Shimon holds: • Even if not valid for eating It still: • Removes impurity Ben Pekua Link Fetus inside animal: • Sometimes does not need its own shechita But: • Depends on conditions Rebbe – Mixing Opinions Rebbe: • Sometimes follows Rav Meir • Sometimes follows Rav Shimon Leading to: • Different rulings in different sugyos Gezeirah Shavah Different sources used: • To define what counts as shechita Leads to: • Different conclusions between opinions Inside the Mikdash Slaughtering non - korban animals there: • Forbidden to benefit from Additional Point from Sugya If shechita is not considered valid: • It may be treated like killing, not shechita נפק״מ : • Affects prohibition and benefit Final יסוד • Rabbi Yosi is strict in doubtful cases • There is a clear machlokes (Rav Meir vs Rav Shimon) • ספק changes halacha significantly • Shechita has two separate effects • Not all mitzvos can be compared • Rebbe combines opinions depending on the sugya • Context (certain vs doubtful) is critical Catch up, review, download previous Dafim & more: https://www.dafchazarah.co.uk Now available as an app (Apple, Google & Amazon): https://dafchazarah.co.uk/download Sponsor a day: https://dafchazarah.co.uk/sponsor לעילוי נשמת אמי מורתי רות בת הרב מנחם מנדל