Daf 100 — Chullin 100 Summary

Chullin 100 – Good Morning Raboisai Gid Hanasheh Mixed with Other Gidim Gemara: Mishnah: • Gid hanasheh was cooked with other permitted gidim • The forbidden gid can no longer be identified Question Why not say: • Bitul b’rov • The one forbidden gid should become nullified in the majority Answer – Beriah A complete gid hanasheh is: • A beriah – a complete entity Therefore: • It is significant • It cannot become batel Three Important Items That Are Not Batel The Gemara discusses three categories of significant items: • Beriah – a complete entity • Davar sheb’minyan – something sold or counted individually • Chatichah har’uyah l’hiskabed – an important piece fit to serve to a guest Piece of Neveilah If a piece of neveilah falls into kosher food: If recognisable: • Remove it • The rest depends on whether its flavor spread If not recognisable: • It may not become batel because it is an important piece Davar Sheb’minyan Rebbe Meir: • Something important enough to be counted individually does not become batel Machlokes Does this mean: • Something always sold individually Or even: • Something sometimes sold individually Chatichah Har’uyah L’hiskabed An important piece of meat: • Fit to be served to a guest Is considered significant and: • Does not become batel Why Both Gid and Neveilah Cases Are Needed Gid hanasheh: • Important because it is a complete entity Piece of neveilah: • Not a complete entity • But important because it can be served to a guest Therefore: • Each case teaches a separate rule Chatichah Atzmah Na’aseis Neveilah Rav teaches an important principle: • A forbidden piece gives flavor to a permitted piece The permitted piece itself then becomes: • Like neveilah Result We now treat it as though: • There are two forbidden pieces Not merely: • The original forbidden piece Why This Matters Example: • One piece of neveilah gives flavor to one kosher piece • That second piece now becomes forbidden When they enter a larger mixture: • Both pieces must be taken into account Min B’mino with Another Food Case: • Forbidden meat • Permitted meat • Potatoes or another different food Normally: • Remove the permitted meat from the calculation • The different food can nullify the forbidden meat But According to Rav Once the permitted meat absorbed the forbidden flavor: • It itself became like neveilah Therefore: • There are now two forbidden pieces • A larger amount is needed to nullify them Example – 60 One forbidden piece: • Needs 60 against it If a second piece becomes forbidden: • Need 120 against the two pieces New Mishnah – Gid Hanasheh of Non - Kosher Animals Tanna Kamma: • Gid hanasheh does not apply to a non - kosher animal Rebbe Yehuda: • It does apply Rebbe Yehuda’s Reason Gid hanasheh originates with: • Yaakov Avinu This was: • Before Matan Torah At that time: • The distinction between kosher and non - kosher animals had not yet been commanded Chachamim’s Response The prohibition was actually given: • At Sinai The Torah simply recorded it: • In the story of Yaakov where it belonged Does Gid Have Flavor? The Gemara discusses whether: • Gid hanasheh has taste If it has no taste: • Eating the gid of a non - kosher animal would not create the normal prohibition of eating non - kosher meat Yet: • The prohibition of gid hanasheh can still apply Rebbe Yehuda – Two Issurim According to the view that gid does have flavor: • Eating the gid of a non - kosher animal can involve two prohibitions Rebbe Yehuda: • Makes one liable for both Ein Issur Chal Al Issur Normally: • A second prohibition cannot take effect on something already forbidden Question The animal’s meat becomes forbidden: • Before the gid fully develops So how can the later prohibition of gid hanasheh take effect? Severe Issur Can Take Effect Answer: • Gid hanasheh is considered a more severe prohibition Why? • According to Rebbe Yehuda, it already applied from the time of Yaakov Avinu • Before the Torah’s later food prohibitions Therefore Because gid hanasheh is more severe: • It can take effect even on something already prohibited Final Points • A complete gid hanasheh is a beriah and does not become batel • Important counted items and pieces fit for guests may also not become batel • Rav teaches chatichah atzmah na’aseis neveilah • A permitted piece can itself become forbidden after absorbing forbidden flavor • This changes how much is required for bitul • Rebbe Yehuda applies gid hanasheh even to non - kosher animals • The Gemara discusses whether gid has flavor • Normally ein issur chal al issur • A more severe prohibition can sometimes take effect on an existing prohibition Catch up, review, download previous Dafim & more: https://www.dafchazarah.co.uk Now available as an app (Apple, Google & Amazon): https://dafchazarah.co.uk/download Sponsor a day: https://dafchazarah.co.uk/sponsor לעילוי נשמת אמי מורתי רות בת הרב מנחם מנדל