Daf 91 — Menachos 91 Summary

Menachos 91 – Good Morning Raboisai Todah & Nesachim From the word “ אֹוי ” : • Todah requires Nesachim • Not included automatically in “Zevach” Reason: • Might think breads replace Nesachim • Chiddush → still requires wine Klal – Prat – Klal Structure Pasuk builds: • Klal → includes all Korbanos • Prat → limits to Neder/Nedavah • Klal → re - expands Rule: Include only things similar to the Prat What is Included Included: • Korbanos not brought for sin • Examples: o Bechor o Maaser o Pesach Also includes: • Vlad Kodshim • Temurah • Olos from surplus funds What is Excluded Excluded: • Chatas • Asham Reason: Come for Kaparah (sin) Multiple “ אֹוי ” in Pasuk Used to separate cases: Scenarios: • Different Korban types • Same Korban, different obligations • Same obligation, different Korban Each requires separate Nesachim Two Korbanos Even if: • Same type (e.g. two Olos) Still require separate Nesachim Nazir / Metzora Cases • Metzora → brings Korbanos with Mincha & Nesachim • Special דין compared to standard Chatas/Asham Chatas & Asham Normally: • Do NOT require Nesachim But: Metzora exception requires them Olas Metzora Pasuk teaches: • Olas Metzora requires Nesachim Not learned from general Olah Olas Yoledes Consideration: • Maybe included Conclusion: • Learned separately → not same limud Ayil of Kohen Gadol (Yom Kippur) Pasuk includes: Requires Nesachim Even though: • Fixed - time Korban Palgas (13th Month Animal) Case: • In - between Kevess and Ayil Din: • Requires Nesachim Machlokes: • Independent category • Or Safek → bring with condition Age Differences • No differentiation in Nesachim: o Between ages (after category set) o Male vs female Final Practical Case Ticket system: • One ticket covered: o All sheep (male & female) Proof: • Same Nesachim for both Key Takeaways • “ אֹוי ” teaches inclusion & separation • Only certain Korbanos require Nesachim • Sin Korbanos generally excluded • Metzora is key exception • Each Korban requires its own Nesachim • No difference male vs female in sheep • Palgas creates unique ספק scenario