Daf 105 — Menachos 105 Summary

Menachos 105 – Good Morning Raboisai Lashon Neder – Singular vs Plural • If he says Isaron (singular) → brings one • If he says Isronim (plural) → brings two Rule: • Plural = minimum of two (not more) Unclear Neder – “Pirashati” Case: • He said a Mincha but doesn’t remember what he said Must bring: • 60 Isaron (maximum possible) Condition Mechanism • If actual chiyuv was less: Remaining amount becomes Nedavah • Must make a tenai (condition) Unspecified Mincha Type • If he says: “I will bring a Mincha” • Tanna Kama: Can bring any of the 5 types • Rebbi Yehuda: Brings Minchas Soles (default) Lashon Variations • “Min Mincha” → one • “Min Minachos” → two Language precision defines obligation Contradictory Lashon Case: • “Mine Mincha” Question: • Does “Mine” (plural) or “Mincha” (singular) control? Remains unresolved (Safek) Forgot Type of Mincha • If unsure which Mincha: Must bring all 5 types Forgot Quantity (Complex Case) • If unsure number of Isaron Tanna Kama: • Bring 60 in total Rebbi: • Bring 1 – 60 individually • Total = 1830 Isaron Difference Between Cases • If vessels NOT specified: Can bring 60 Isaron in separate keilim • If vessels ARE specified: Must account for every possible amount Why Soles is Default • Considered: Most “standard” Mincha Not tied to a special name New Safek Case • “Mine Mincha” Cannot learn clearly from Mishnah • Could mean: o One o Two o Or mixed types Five Types of Mincha • Machvas • Marcheshes • Soles • Chalos • Rekikin Shitas Rebbi Shimon • Chalos & Rekikin: Can be mixed in different ratios Creates multiple combinations Practical Impact • If unsure: Must account for all combinations Using Tenai (Condition) • Allows combining: o Chiyuv o Nedavah Within same Mincha Nazir / Metzora Case (Parallel Idea) • Person unsure of status Uses conditional Korbanos • Applies all possibilities with stringencies Limitation of Conditions • Cannot create: “Beis HaPsul” (waste of Kodshim) • Only allowed where no loss occurs Mincha Advantage • All eaten within same timeframe No Beis HaPsul issue Mixing for Kmitzah • Must ensure: One valid Kmitzah • Solution: Combine pieces before taking Kmitzah Key Takeaways • Lashon Neder precisely determines obligation • Safek requires covering all possible outcomes • Tenai is a powerful halachic tool • Mincha has flexibility due to uniform rules • Exact wording can drastically change obligations • Combinations increase complexity in uncertain cases • Proper Kmitzah requires valid unified mixture Catch up, review, download previous Dafim & more: www.dafchazarah.co.uk Now available as an app (Apple, Google & Amazon) – see website for details Sponsor a day: https://dafchazarah.co.uk/sponsor לעילוי נשמת אמי מורתי רות בת הרב מנחם מנדל