Daf 89 — Menachos 89 Summary

Menachos 89 – Good Morning Raboisai Todah – Amount of Oil Pasuk says “ בשמן ” twice : • Without repetition → would think 1 Log oil (like all Menachos) • Double expression → reduces to Half Log Rule: • Ribui after Ribui → comes to limit How Oil is Divided Todah has 3 types: • Chalos • Rekikin • Revuchah From extra “ בשמן ”: Revuchah gets more oil Distribution: • Total = Half Log • Split: o Chalos → 1/8 Log o Rekikin → 1/8 Log o Revuchah → 1/4 Log Rebbi Akiva Disagrees: Entire דין is Halacha L’Moshe MiSinai Includes: • Todah = Half Log oil • Revuchah gets Revi’is Log • 11 days of Zivah Mincha Oil – Machlokes Pasuk: “Isaron balul baLog Shemen” • Chachamim: o Every Isaron → needs 1 Log • Others: o Even large Mincha → only 1 Log total Poor Metzora • Regular Metzora → 3 Korbanos → 3 Isaron • Poor Metzora → 1 Korban → 1 Isaron Cannot exempt entirely from Mincha Minimum Mincha From “LaMincha baLog Shemen”: Minimum donation: • Must be at least 1 Isaron (requires 1 Log oil) Measurements from Hin Hin = 12 Log Therefore: • Half Hin → 6 Log (Par) • Third Hin → 4 Log (Ayil) • Quarter Hin → 3 Log (Keves) Menorah Oil From “ מערב עד בקר ”: Must last entire night Shiur: • Half Log per lamp How Shiur Was Determined Two approaches: • Start from large → reduce • Start from small → increase Consideration: • Avoid wasting oil vs. not acting cheaply in Mikdash Mixing Nesachim • Bull & ram → can mix (same ratio) • Sheep → cannot mix (different ratio) If mixed: • After proper mixing → kosher • Before mixing → pasul Wine Mixing Final explanation: • Mixing refers to wine only Rules: • If oil/flour already offered → can mix wine • If not → do not mix (concern for mixing oil/flour) Omer Korban • Comes with 2 Isaron flour • But: o Wine remains standard (not doubled) o Oil also follows wine Asham Metzora (Wrong Intent) If brought not lishmah: • Continue Avodah • Must still bring Nesachim Otherwise: Korban becomes pasul General Rule If Korban done incorrectly: • Continue Avodah as valid Korban type • Must include all required components Key Takeaways • Todah oil = Half Log (from repeated “ בשמן ”) • Revuchah gets larger portion • Major machlokes on Mincha oil amounts • Hin = 12 Log foundation • Menorah requires Half Log per lamp • Mixing depends on ratios and stage • Wrong intent requires continuing full process