Daf 82 — Chullin 82 Summary

Chullin 82 – Good Morning Raboisai אותו ואת בנו – Must Be Shechita Gemara: The איסור applies only if: • Both animals are properly slaughtered If one is killed (not shechita): • No איסור רבי שמעון – שחיטה ראויה Principle: • Only a shechita that allows eating counts Examples If animal is: • טריפה • עבודה זרה • Other forbidden cases Then: • Not considered valid shechita Parah Adumah Case Listed as: • Not edible מסקנה Removed from Mishnah Because: • It can potentially be redeemed → considered edible Egl Arufah Case Also listed as: • Not edible מסקנה Also removed from Mishnah Reason: • In some cases could still be permitted When Does Egl Arufah Become Forbidden? Key point: • Once brought down to the valley Before that: • Could still be released Metzora Birds Comparison Similar idea: • Become forbidden at a certain stage Compared to: • Egl Arufah New Sugya – Selling Mother & Child Two buyers: • One buys mother • One buys child דין First buyer: • Has right to slaughter first Reason Seller gives up rights: • Cannot give second buyer more rights If Second Buyer Acts First If he did not know: • Allowed If he knew: • Acting improperly זריז ונשכר One who acts quickly: • Gains benefit Example: • Gets the meat Multiple Offspring Case If slaughter: • Mother + two children Each pair: • Separate prohibition Complex Case Slaughter order: • Grandmother • Granddaughter • Then middle (daughter) Result מחלוקת : תנא קמא : • One set of lashes סומכוס : • Two sets יסוד המחלוקת Are multiple issurim: • One action → one liability Or: • Count separately Comparison – Other Issurim Example: • Eating multiple forbidden pieces Debate: • One or multiple punishments Final יסוד • Must have valid shechita to create issur • Not all cases in Mishnah are valid → some removed • Timing determines status (Egl Arufah etc.) • Ownership rights affect who can slaughter • Multiple relationships can create multiple issurim • Debate if one act = one or multiple liabilities Catch up, review, download previous Dafim & more: https://www.dafchazarah.co.uk Now available as an app (Apple, Google & Amazon): https://dafchazarah.co.uk/download Sponsor a day: https://dafchazarah.co.uk/sponsor לעילוי נשמת אמי מורתי רות בת הרב מנחם מנדל