Daf 90 — Menachos 90 Summary

Menachos 90 – Good Morning Raboisai Measuring Keilim – Heaped vs Flat • All measuring keilim were heaped (gadush) • Except: o Kohen Gadol’s Mincha → measured flat (machuk) Reason: • Easier to divide and carry Overflow ( בירוצין ) • Liquid measurements → overflow is kadosh • Dry measurements → overflow is not kadosh Machlokes – Source of Kedusha Three views: Tanna Kama • Liquid keli → kadosh inside & outside • Dry keli → kadosh inside only Rebbi Akiva • Dry keli → no kedusha at all • Kedusha comes from verbal designation Rebbi Yossi • No kedusha outside • Overflow becomes kadosh because it came from inside Kedusha Without Daas Question: • Does overflow need owner’s intent? Answer: • Kli shares can be mekadesh even without daas Lechem HaPanim – Lina Case: • Bread placed on Sunday Result: • Not pasul due to lina • Only becomes pasul after proper Shabbos cycle Moiser Nesachim Not overflow Rather: • Extra supply due to pricing agreement Rule: • Hekdesh always benefits Use: • Sold → money used for Kayitz HaMizbeach Kayitz HaMizbeach • When Mizbeach idle • Bring Olos from surplus funds What Gets Nesachim General rule: Only Korbanos brought as Nedavah require Nesachim Includes: • Olah • Shelamim • Todah What Does NOT Get Nesachim Five: • Bechor • Maaser • Pesach • Chatas • Asham Exceptions • Asham Metzora → requires Nesachim • Chatas Metzora → related דין Korbanos of Yom Tov Includes: • Olas Re’iyah • Shalmei Chagigah • Shalmei Simchah Source – Pasuk Structure • “Zevach” → Shelamim • “Olah” → Olah • “Oi” → Todah Excludes: • Obligatory Korbanos Bird Korbanos Excluded: • Do NOT require Nesachim Neder Language If one says “Olah”: • Might think → bring both cattle & sheep Pasuk teaches: Only one type required Key Takeaways • Liquid overflow can become kadosh • Dry overflow does not • Kedusha source debated • Surplus funds go to Mizbeach • Nesachim apply mainly to Nedavah Korbanos • Several key exceptions exist