Daf 107 — Menachos 107 Summary

Menachos 107 – Good Morning Raboisai Donating Wood as a Korban • A person can donate wood as a korban It has dinim like a korban: • Requires salt • Requires hagasha (touching Mizbeach) • Requires a form of kmitzah (breaking pieces) Wood Requires Its Own Fire • Wood korban is not burned directly Must: • First build a fire • Then place the wood korban on top Levonah Minimum • Donating Levonah → must be at least one kmitzah Learned from hekesh to Mincha “Harei Alai Lamizbeach” • If a person says: “I accept something for the Mizbeach” Brings: • Levonah (minimum amount) Reason: • It is fully consumed on the Mizbeach Fully Burned Principle • We assume he meant something: Completely burned (no portion for Kohanim) Why Not Other Korbanos? • Animal korbanos → parts go to Kohanim • Bird korban → some parts removed Not fully burned Nesachim Question • Wine (Nesachim) also fully used But: • Goes into Shittin , not directly burned Conclusion Levonah is the simplest fully - burned offering Donations – Minimum Amounts • Gold → minimum 1 dinar • Silver → minimum 1 dinar • Copper → minimum useful כלי • Iron → usable amount (e.g. spikes) Purpose - Based Amounts • Must be: Something practical and usable Wine Donation • Minimum → 3 log Based on smallest Nesachim (sheep) Oil Donation Machlokes: • Chachamim → 1 log • Rebbi → 3 log Source of Machlokes • Do we learn: Full comparison (amount included)? Or just concept (amount learned elsewhere)? Unspecified Amount • If person forgot amount Bring like maximum day (Sukkos) • Total → 140 log Animal Neder – Cheapest Option • If unclear which korban Bring cheapest valid option If Completely Unclear • Must bring multiple types Covers all possibilities Exact Specification Matters • If he said: o Black → must bring black o White → must bring white o Small → must bring small Cannot substitute Large vs Small (Machlokes) • Chachamim → larger may work • Rebbi → must match exactly Value Specification • If he said: “Worth 100” Must bring exactly that • Two items of 50 ≠ one of 100 Key Takeaways • Even wood can be a korban with full halachic process • Levonah is the default fully - burned offering • Minimum donation amounts depend on practical use • Oil donation has a key machlokes (1 vs 3 log) • Unclear neder requires covering all possibilities • Cheapest valid option is used when unspecified • Exact wording (colour, size, value) is binding Catch up, review, download previous Dafim & more: https://www.dafchazarah.co.uk Now available as an app (Apple, Google & Amazon): https://dafchazarah.co.uk/download Sponsor a day: https://dafchazarah.co.uk/sponsor לעילוי נשמת אמי מורתי רות בת הרב מנחם מנדל