Daf 33 — Chullin 33 Summary

Chullin 33 – Good Morning Raboisai ריש לקיש – Status After Cutting One סימן Gemara: ריש לקיש teaches: Once the קנה (trachea) is cut It is considered: • As if removed from the body Result Anything connected to it (like lungs): • No longer considered part of the animal Therefore: • Cannot make it טריפה by damaging those parts Limitation – רבא רבא argues: This only applies to: • Organs connected to the קנה (like lungs) But: • Other organs (like intestines / קישקע ) Still considered part of the animal Therefore: • Can still become טריפה רבי זירא – “Half Dead Animal” רבי זירא says: After cutting one סימן Animal is: • Half - dead (50%) Logic Just like: • A fully dead animal cannot become טריפה So too: • A half - dead animal should not become טריפה Conclusion רבי זירא later questions this Not clearly accepted Core Question – Combining סימנים Case: • First סימן cut → normal • Then: Intestines punctured (animal becomes טריפה ) • Then second סימן cut Question Can the two סימנים combine? Problem • First סימן accomplishes: o Eating permitted o Removes נבילה • Second סימן : o Only removes טומאה o Cannot permit eating (already טריפה ) Can two different “types” combine? Question remains בן פקועה (Fetus Case) Case: • Fetus inside mother Mother’s shechita permits fetus Scenario • Fetus sticks limb out between two סימנים Question Does second סימן complete validity? Or: • Since it does not fully permit → cannot combine Same יסוד as before Key Clarification רבי זירא ’s question is: • About טומאה (נבילה) But: • He assumes the animal is already טריפה Therefore: • Shows he does NOT hold “half - dead = cannot become טריפה ” איבר מן החי – Detached Organ Case: • Kidney removed from live animal Status: • אבר מן החי Remains אסור even after shechita Rule Once detached while alive: • Never becomes permitted Extension – Intestines ( קישקע ) Same rule applies If detached while animal alive → אסור forever Critical Case Case: • One סימן cut • Animal still physically alive • Then intestine detached Question For a Jew: • Shechita already works For a non - Jew: • Animal still alive So is this: • אבר מן החי ? Huge חידוש יוצא : • Jew → מותר • Non - Jew → אסור Challenge How can something be: • Permitted to Jew • Forbidden to non - Jew? Proof Against Case: • One cuts piece of meat right after shechita • Before full death Source says: • Permitted even for non - Jew Conclusion Rejects previous חידוש No difference between Jew and non - Jew New Sugya – הכשר לקבל טומאה Food becomes susceptible to טומאה only after contact with liquids Question What about meat after shechita? Blood as Liquid Normally: • Blood = one of 7 liquids Makes food susceptible Case No blood came out רבי שמעון Holds: • Shechita itself prepares meat No need for liquid Problem – Hands are שני Hands are: • שני לטומאה (midrabbanan) שני cannot affect: • חולין Question Why would touching meat matter? Answer Case: • Hands became ראשון לטומאה How By entering: • בית המת / בית המנוגע Result ראשון can affect חולין Therefore: • Meat becomes טמא רבי עקיבא Teaches: • שני can make שלישי in חולין חידוש Normally חולין stops at שני רבי עקיבא extends further Limitation This applies: • Only in certain cases Not universally accepted Final יסוד • Cutting one סימן does not fully define status • טריפה can still occur mid - process • איבר מן החי remains אסור permanently • No difference between Jew and non - Jew in this case • הכשר טומאה depends on liquid or shechita • Hands can become ראשון in certain cases Key Takeaways (English) • Cutting one siman may detach parts conceptually (Reish Lakish) • Other organs can still become treifa (Rava) • Question: can two different types of shechita results combine • Ben Pekuah case parallels this issue • Detached limb while alive remains forbidden permanently • Discussion whether status differs for Jew vs non - Jew (rejected) • Meat requires preparation to receive tumah • Blood usually enables this, but shechita may suffice • Hands normally cannot affect chullin unless they become rishon Catch up, review, download previous Dafim & more: https://www.dafchazarah.co.uk Now available as an app (Apple, Google & Amazon): https://dafchazarah.co.uk/download Sponsor a day: https://dafchazarah.co.uk/sponsor To receive the daf summary daily join our group: https://chat.whatsapp.com/L4AiVVxQwYqLRh4RtMAlGE Daf Chazarah Bot (Request any PDF – past or current): Save the number +44 7427 857802 and message to get instant access Direct link: https://dafchazarah.co.uk/whatsapp לעילוי נשמת אמי מורתי רות בת הרב מנחם מנדל לע״נ הרבנית הצדקנית ממעזיבוז׳ מרת רחל בת מתתיהו ע״ה