Daf 93 — Menachos 93 Summary

Menachos 93 – Good Morning Raboisai Yorish – Smicha & Temurah Machlokes: • Mishnah (Rebbi Meir) → Yorish does Smicha & Temurah • Rebbi Yehuda → Yorish does NOT do Smicha or Temurah Source of Rebbi Yehuda From “Karbano” : Must be his own Korban → Not inherited Therefore: • No Smicha • No Temurah Rabbanan From “Hamer Yimir” : Includes Yorish Therefore: • Yorish DOES Temurah • And therefore DOES Smicha Additional Limudim from “Karbano” • Not your friend’s Korban • Not a goy’s Korban • All partners must do Smicha Women & Temurah Machlokes how learned: • Rebbi Yehuda → from “Yamir” • Rabbanan → from extra letter Who Does Smicha “All do Smicha” except: • Cheresh • Shoteh • Katan • Blind • Nochri • Eved • Shliach • Isha Reason: Requires da’as and personal action Smicha – Not Me’akev • Called “Shiyarei Mitzvah” • If not done → Korban still valid BUT: Considered lacking Kaparah Smicha vs Kaparah • Kaparah comes from Zerikas HaDam • Not from Smicha BUT: Smicha still essential for complete Kaparah Smicha & Shechita Rule: Must be immediately before Shechita Done in same place How Smicha is Done • With both hands • On the head Not: • Neck • Back • Sides No Barrier Must be direct contact: • No cloth • No gloves “Yadav” = Two Hands From wording: Even though written singular → means two hands Final Rule Smicha must be: • By the owner • With both hands • On the head • Immediately before Shechita Key Takeaways • Machlokes if Yorish does Smicha • Smicha must be by true owner • Not done via shliach or others • Requires both hands, direct contact • Not me’akev, but completes Kaparah