בכורות•Bechoros

    Daf 56 — Bechoros 56 Summary

    Bechoros 56 summary · Daf Yomi chazarah notes

    56

    Daily chazarah summary for Bechoros Daf 56

    Uploaded November 14, 2026
    Share:

    View PDF

    Open in New Tab

    דף היומי סיכום — Bechoros 56

    די איבערזעצונג איז נאָך נישט גרייט. דער ענגלישער סיכום ווערט געוויזן.

    Bechoros 56 – Good Morning Raboisai The Four Rivers and Nahar Pras The Daf continues the discussion of Nahar Pras – the Euphrates. The Torah describes one river flowing from Gan Eden and then dividing into four: Pishon Gichon Chidekel Pras The Gemara asks: If the other rivers ultimately come from Pras, why does the Torah list Pras as though it is simply the fourth river? The answer comes from the wording: “V’Hanahar HaRevi’i Hu Pras.” “Hu Pras” indicates: This is the river referred to earlier as flowing from Eden. Pras is therefore treated as the fundamental source. Pras Is Also Called Yuval Rebbe Meir teaches: Pras is also called Yuval. The Daf connects this to the Pasuk describing a tree: Sending its roots toward the Yuval. This leads into a major practical discussion: Where does the water in a river actually come from? That question has significant consequences for Hilchos Mikvaos. River Water and Mikvah Mayan vs Rainwater There is an important distinction between: A Mayan – spring water emerging naturally from the ground. and: Rainwater collected as a Mikvah. A Mayan has special Halachos: Its water may flow – Zochalin. Rainwater used for a Mikvah: Must generally be gathered and stationary. Therefore, if a river contains a large amount of rainwater: Its status can become a serious Halachic issue. Rain in Eretz Yisrael and the Pras The Daf discusses the relationship between: Rainfall and: The rising waters of the Pras. When there is substantial rainfall: The river can rise considerably. The question becomes: Is the increased water primarily: Natural spring water from the river's source? or: Rainwater entering the river? That distinction affects whether one may immerse in the flowing river. Shmuel’s Father and the Mikvah A Mikvah for His Daughters The Gemara relates that: Shmuel's father prepared a Mikvah for his daughters during Nissan. Why not simply allow them to immerse in the river? Because during that period: There was concern that the river contained a majority of rainwater. If the majority is rainwater: Flowing water cannot simply be treated as a Mayan. Therefore: He arranged a proper stationary Mikvah. Mats During Tishrei During Tishrei there was a different practical problem. With less water in the river: Mud and sediment accumulated at the bottom. This could interfere with proper immersion. Therefore: Mats were placed down. The goal was to avoid a possible: Chatzitzah between the person and the water. The Daf therefore gives us two different concerns: Nissan – too much rainwater. Tishrei – mud and sediment. Shmuel and the Pras The Gemara discusses Shmuel's statement concerning immersion in the Pras. At certain times: The river can be relied upon as natural flowing spring water. But when rainfall substantially increases its volume: There is concern that the majority may be rainwater. This creates the central Halachic question: Is the river still functioning as a Mayan, or has rainwater become dominant? Back to Ma’aser Behemah A Purchased Animal The Daf returns to Ma’aser Behemah. Suppose a person has: Nine animals born in his possession. He then: Purchases a tenth animal. Can the purchased animal join the other nine for Ma’aser Behemah? No. Likewise, an animal received as a gift does not simply join his own animals for the Ma’aser count. The Comparison to Bechor The source comes from the Pasuk connecting: Bechor of a person with: Bechor of cattle and sheep. The Torah says: “Kein Ta’aseh…” But what “doing” is there with a human Bechor? A firstborn son: Becomes a Bechor naturally. The father does not perform an action to make him a Bechor. Therefore, the words: “Kein Ta’aseh” must teach us something about the animals. The Gemara derives: Animals purchased from elsewhere are excluded from the normal Ma’aser Behemah count. Why Apply the Pasuk to Ma’aser Behemah? Perhaps It Refers to a Chatas? The Gemara challenges the derivation. Perhaps “Kein Ta’aseh” teaches a rule regarding: A Chatas. Maybe an animal purchased from elsewhere cannot be designated as a Chatas. The Gemara rejects this. A Chatas comes: Because of a Chet. A human Bechor does not arise because of a Chet. Therefore: Chatas is not sufficiently comparable. What About an Olah or Shelamim? Perhaps the comparison refers to: An Olah or: A Shelamim. These do not necessarily come because of a sin. But they can be brought as: A Neder or Nedavah. That too is unlike a human Bechor, which: Does not arise through a voluntary pledge. So these possibilities are also rejected. What About Olas Re’iyah? The Gemara considers: Olas Re’iyah. This is obligatory when going to the Beis HaMikdash on Yom Tov. It is: Not brought because of a Chet. Not a voluntary Neder or Nedavah. Perhaps “Kein Ta’aseh” refers to this? The Gemara distinguishes it because: Olas Re’iyah has a fixed time. A Bechor: Has no predetermined time when it must be born. Ma’aser Behemah Is the Best Comparison After eliminating the alternatives: Ma’aser Behemah remains the appropriate comparison. Like Bechor: It is not caused by a Chet. It is not a Neder or Nedavah. It does not depend upon a fixed festival date. Therefore the Pasuk teaches: A purchased animal is excluded from Ma’aser Behemah. Buying an Unborn Animal What if It Was Purchased Before Birth? The Gemara now asks a fascinating question. Suppose the person purchases: An unborn animal while it is still inside its mother. Afterwards: It is born in his possession. Does it count for Ma’aser Behemah? The Daf distinguishes between: Buying an animal once it is already fit for the Mitzvah and: Acquiring it before it has reached that stage. An unborn animal: Is not yet capable of entering the Ma’aser pen. Therefore: It can later be included after birth. Ten Fetuses The Gemara gives the case: A person purchases ten unborn animals. They are subsequently: All born in his possession. These animals can enter: The Ma’aser Behemah count. Why? Because at the time they were purchased: They were not yet fit for the Mitzvah of Ma’aser Behemah. What About an Animal Less Than Eight Days Old? Mechusar Zman This raises the next question. A Korban normally cannot be brought until: The eighth day of its life. During its first seven days it is: Mechusar Zman. So perhaps an animal purchased when it is only: Three or four days old should also be allowed into the Ma’aser count. After all: It is not yet fit to be brought as a Korban. Rebbi Elazar’s Dream Rebbi Elazar says: He saw Rebbi Yochanan in a dream. This indicated to him that: He would have a good explanation of the Sugya. The discussion focuses on whether: The exclusion of a purchased animal applies even when it is Mechusar Zman. Rebbi Shimon – It Can Already Enter the Pen The Gemara brings the view of Rebbi Shimon. According to Rebbi Shimon: An animal less than eight days old may already be included in the Ma’aser Behemah count. Although it cannot yet be offered as a Korban: It can already become Ma’aser. Therefore, once the animal is born: It is already considered fit for the Ma’aser process. If it is purchased after birth: The exclusion of Lakuach applies. The Critical Difference We therefore have a clear distinction: Before birth: The animal cannot yet enter the Ma’aser pen. Purchasing it does not disqualify it later. After birth: It can already participate in Ma’aser Behemah according to Rebbi Shimon. Purchasing it can disqualify it from the count. So the key question is not simply: Can it already be brought as a Korban? Rather: Is it already fit for the Mitzvah of Ma’aser Behemah? Esnan and Ma’aser Behemah An Animal Given as Payment The Daf introduces another unusual case: An animal given to a Zonah as payment. Such an animal can have the status of: Esnan Zonah. An Esnan is prohibited from being brought as: A Korban. The Gemara discusses what happens if the animal is later reacquired and becomes involved in: Ma’aser Behemah. But It Was Purchased Back! The obvious problem is: If the man buys the animal back, it is now a purchased animal. A Lakuach: Is excluded from Ma’aser Behemah! How, then, can the case work? Rebbi Yochanan explains: The transaction occurred while the animal was still a fetus. He gave her rights to: An unborn animal and later reacquired those rights: Before birth. Since the animal was purchased while still in the womb: It was not yet fit for Ma’aser Behemah. Therefore, the normal exclusion of Lakuach does not apply. A Zonah Nochris Why Is the Woman a Non - Jew? The Gemara asks why the case is specifically: A Zonah Nochris. Why not discuss: A Jewish Zonah? The answer reveals an important Chiddush concerning the Torah prohibition of: Esnan Zonah. Which Esnan Is Prohibited? The Daf teaches that the Torah's category of Esnan Zonah applies in the case where: The relationship is one in which Kiddushin cannot take effect. The Gemara derives this through a comparison to: Arayos. Just as with Arayos: Kiddushin does not take effect, so too the relevant definition of Zonah here involves: A relationship where Kiddushin cannot take effect. Therefore, the Gemara distinguishes: A Zonah Nochris from: The Jewish case being discussed. Key Chazarah • The Daf begins with Nahar Pras and the four rivers flowing from Gan Eden. • “Hu Pras” identifies Pras with the river described as flowing from Eden. • Pras is also called Yuval. • The Daf discusses the crucial difference between Mayan water and rainwater for Mikvah. • A Mayan can remain valid while flowing; collected rainwater generally must be stationary. • Shmuel's father prepared a Mikvah during Nissan because of concern that rainwater had become the majority of the river. • During Tishrei, mats were used because mud and sediment could interfere with immersion. • The Daf then returns to Ma’aser Behemah. • An animal purchased or received as a gift after it is fit for Ma’aser Behemah is excluded from the count. • This is learned through the Torah's comparison with Bechor. • The Gemara considers and rejects applying the Pasuk to Chatas, Olah, Shelamim and Olas Re’iyah. • An unborn animal purchased while still in its mother's womb can later be included in Ma’aser Behemah. • Ten purchased fetuses that are subsequently born can therefore be tithed. • According to Rebbi Shimon, even an animal less than eight days old can already enter the Ma’aser Behemah count. • Therefore, once it is born, purchasing it can create the problem of Lakuach even though it cannot yet be brought as a Korban. • The key distinction is whether the animal was fit for the Ma’aser process when purchased. • The Daf discusses an Esnan Zonah that was transferred and reacquired while still a fetus. • The discussion concludes with the definition of the Torah's Esnan Zonah and its connection to whether Kiddushin can take effect. Catch up, review, download previous Dafim & more: https://www.dafchazarah.co.uk Now available as an app (Apple, Google & Amazon): https://dafchazarah.co.uk/download Sponsor a day: https://dafchazarah.co.uk/sponsor לעילוי נשמת אמי מורתי רות בת הרב מנחם מנדל

    Translations

    Click a language below to generate a free translation: