בכורות•Bechoros
Daf 59 — Bechoros 59 Summary
Bechoros 59 summary · Daf Yomi chazarah notes
59
Daily chazarah summary for Bechoros Daf 59
Uploaded November 16, 2026
Share:
View PDF
דף היומי סיכום — Bechoros 59
די איבערזעצונג איז נאָך נישט גרייט. דער ענגלישער סיכום ווערט געוויזן.
Bechoros 59 – Good Morning Raboisai How Is Ma’aser Behemah Performed? The Daf continues with the actual procedure of Ma’aser Behemah. The animals are placed: Inside a pen. A small opening is made: Narrow enough that two animals cannot leave together. The mothers stand outside, and the young animals: Hear their mothers and naturally come towards them. The animals must leave: On their own. The owner should not simply push them through himself. Why Not Lure Them With Food? Why not place vegetables outside and allow the animals to follow the food? The Gemara is concerned that this could attract: Every animal in the pen. That could include animals which are not eligible for Ma’aser Behemah, such as: Purchased animals. Animals excluded because of their circumstances of birth. The proper system is therefore: For the animals to naturally follow their mothers. A Treifah Cannot Pass Through The Torah describes: Animals passing under the staff. This excludes: A Treifah that cannot properly pass through under its own power. Therefore: A Treifah is excluded from Ma’aser Behemah. Counting the Animals The Staff and the Red Mark The proper procedure is: Count the animals one by one as they leave. Use a staff during the counting. Mark the tenth animal with red paint. However: These details are the ideal procedure but are not all Me’akev. If the tenth animal was not painted: It can still become Ma’aser. What if the Animals Never Leave the Pen? Suppose the animals are simply standing or sitting in the pen and the owner points: One, two, three… ten. Can the tenth become Ma’aser? The Daf discusses whether: The actual passing through the opening is essential, or whether: Counting and designation can work even while the animals remain in place. Can You Simply Take Ten Percent? Suppose someone owns: One hundred animals. Instead of counting every tenth animal, he simply selects: Ten animals as Ma’aser. Does that work? According to the main view: No. Ma’aser Behemah requires: The tenth animal itself. The Torah says: “Ha’Asiri” – the tenth. You must count: One, two, three… until reaching ten. Rebbi Yosi B’Rebbi Yehudah Rebbi Yosi B’Rebbi Yehudah disagrees. He holds: Ma’aser Behemah can work through Machshavah. His reasoning comes from: The laws of Terumah and Ma’aser Dagan. Ma’aser Through Machshavah Terumah Can Be Designated in Your Mind The Daf explains that: Terumah Gedolah and: Terumas Ma’aser can be designated through Machshavah. A person can look at his produce and mentally decide: This portion will be Terumah. He does not necessarily need: A verbal declaration. Ma’aser Dagan Is Called Terumah The Torah itself refers to Ma’aser in connection with: Terumah. Therefore: Ma’aser Dagan shares this ability to be designated through Machshavah. The Gemara then connects: Ma’aser Dagan to: Ma’aser Behemah. From here comes the view that: Ma’aser Behemah can also take effect through Machshavah. The Tenth Animal Becomes Kadosh Automatically Rava’s Major Chiddush Rava teaches: Asiri Me’eilav Kadosh. The tenth animal becomes Kadosh: Automatically. Even if the owner does not explicitly say: “This is the tenth.” The tenth animal can receive: Kedushas Ma’aser on its own. The Gemara now searches for the source of this remarkable Halachah. Calling the Ninth “Ten” The Gemara discusses a person who becomes confused while counting. Suppose: The ninth animal comes out. By mistake, he calls it: “Ten.” This can create a degree of Kedushah on the ninth animal. It is not treated like an ordinary Ma’aser animal: But it cannot simply be eaten immediately. Instead: He waits until it develops a Mum and can then eat it. What Happens to the Real Tenth? Now the actual tenth animal arrives. Suppose: The owner says nothing at all. The Gemara uses this case to investigate: Whether the real tenth becomes Ma’aser automatically. If it does: That supports Rava’s principle of Asiri Me’eilav Kadosh. What About Number Eleven? Calling Eleven “Ten” There is another unusual Halachah. If the owner mistakenly calls: Number eleven “ten,” under the appropriate circumstances: Number eleven can become a Shelamim. This is a stronger Kedushah than the mistaken ninth. So we have three different possibilities: Number nine – partial Kedushah. Number ten – actual Ma’aser Behemah. Number eleven – can become a Shelamim. Why Must There Be a Mistake on Number Ten? The Gemara explains that number eleven cannot simply become Kadosh whenever someone calls it ten. If the real number ten was correctly established as Ma’aser: The count is finished. Number eleven is now effectively: Number one of a new count. Calling number one “ten”: Does nothing. Therefore, for number eleven to acquire its special Kedushah: Something must have gone wrong with number ten. The Proof for Rava The Tenth Remains Inside the Pen The Gemara eventually reaches the decisive case. The owner mistakenly calls: Number nine “ten.” The real tenth animal: Remains inside the pen. Yet the Braisa teaches: The real tenth is Ma’aser. This is the proof: The tenth did not need to leave. The owner did not need to verbally declare it. It becomes Kadosh: Automatically. This establishes Rava’s principle: Asiri Me’eilav Kadosh. Is the Ninth Always Kadosh? A Machlokes About Number Nine The Gemara brings a Braisa indicating: The mistaken ninth can sometimes remain completely Chullin. This is explained according to: Rebbi Shimon Ben Yehudah. According to this view: Calling number nine “ten” is not enough by itself. There must also be: A mistake involving the actual tenth animal. Only then: Can the mistaken ninth receive Kedushah. The Kal Vachomer The reasoning is: Number eleven receives: A stronger Kedushah – it can become a Shelamim. Yet that only happens: When there was also a mistake regarding number ten. Therefore, one might argue: Certainly number nine, with its weaker Kedushah, should also require a mistake regarding number ten. The Chachamim Disagree The Chachamim turn the logic around. Perhaps number eleven requires a mistake at number ten precisely because: We are trying to create such a powerful Kedushah. But number nine receives: A much weaker Kedushah. Therefore: Calling the ninth “ten” may itself be sufficient. The Gemara explores both ways of understanding the comparison. Minyan HaRa’ui Poter Rava’s Second Major Principle Rava teaches another important rule: Minyan HaRa’ui Poter. If the counting began with: A valid group of ten animals, then animals which have already been counted can become exempt: Even if the full Ma’aser process is later interrupted. The important point is: The count began when a valid ten were present. What if One Animal Dies? Suppose: Ten animals are placed in the pen. The owner counts: Five animals out. Then: One animal dies. What happens depends on: Which animal died. One of the Counted Animals Dies If one of the animals that already left and was counted dies: The owner continues counting. The remaining animals can: Complete the Ma’aser process. The count itself: Remains valid. An Uncounted Animal Dies But suppose: Five animals were already counted out. Then one of the animals still inside the pen: Dies. Now there are no longer enough animals: To complete the original ten. Nevertheless, the animals already counted: Are exempt. Why? Because when they were counted: They were part of a Minyan HaRa’ui – a valid group capable of reaching ten. What Happens to the Animals Still Inside? The animals which: Never entered the count are different. They can later: Join other animals. For example: If four remain, another six can later join them to form a new group of ten. But the animals already counted: Cannot simply be returned and counted again. Once It Passed, It Passed “Ya’avor” – Not One That Already Passed The source is the Torah’s wording: “Ya’avor” – it shall pass. The Gemara understands this as excluding: An animal which has already passed through the count. Once an animal was legitimately counted as part of: A Minyan HaRa’ui, it is finished with that Ma’aser obligation. Even if the process later breaks down: It does not go back into another Ma’aser count. Key Chazarah • Ma’aser Behemah is performed by placing the animals in a pen and allowing them to leave one at a time. • The opening should be narrow enough that two animals cannot leave together. • The young animals naturally follow the voices of their mothers standing outside. • The owner should not simply push the animals through himself. • A Treifah which cannot properly pass under its own power is excluded. • Lechatchila, the animals are counted with a staff and the tenth is marked with red paint. • These details are not all Me’akev. • According to the main view, one cannot simply take ten animals from one hundred; the tenth must emerge through a count. • Rebbi Yosi B’Rebbi Yehudah connects Ma’aser Behemah to Ma’aser Dagan and allows designation through Machshavah. • Terumah Gedolah and Terumas Ma’aser can be designated through Machshavah. • Rava teaches the major principle: Asiri Me’eilav Kadosh – the tenth animal can become Kadosh automatically. • If number nine is mistakenly called “ten,” it can acquire a degree of Kedushah. • Under the appropriate circumstances, number eleven mistakenly called “ten” can become a Shelamim. • Number eleven can only receive this status when something went wrong with the actual tenth. • The decisive proof for Rava is a case where the real tenth remains inside the pen yet becomes Ma’aser automatically. • Rebbi Shimon Ben Yehudah holds that the mistaken ninth requires a mistake involving number ten before it receives Kedushah. • Rava also teaches: Minyan HaRa’ui Poter. • If a valid group of ten existed when counting began, animals already counted can remain exempt even if the process later cannot be completed. • If one of the already - counted animals dies, the count can continue. • If an uncounted animal inside dies, the animals already counted remain exempt, while those still inside can later join a new group. • Once an animal has legitimately passed through as part of a valid count, it does not return for another Ma’aser count. Catch up, review, download previous Dafim & more: https://www.dafchazarah.co.uk Now available as an app (Apple, Google & Amazon): https://dafchazarah.co.uk/download Sponsor a day: https://dafchazarah.co.uk/sponsor לעילוי נשמת אמי מורתי רות בת הרב מנחם מנדל 59_transcript
Translations
Click a language below to generate a free translation: